Updated October 2026
Carbon offsetting means compensating for the amount of carbon a particular activity creates, by absorbing it elsewhere.
Common examples are planting trees or funding green initiatives in other parts of the globe.
It sounds like a great way to neutralise our carbon output, and many companies including airlines have sold carbon offsets as a way to continue to fly without causing any harm to the planet.
But does carbon offsetting actually work? Is it possible to fly carbon neutral?
Offestting schemes ineffective
An EU report from 2017 showed that 85% of offset schemes failed to remove the necessary carbon. According to the report, most of the projects made false assumptions about carbon savings, or the projects were likely to have happened anyway, i.e. buying an offset didn’t result in ‘additional’ savings.
Another report concluded that companies buying offsets predominately use low-quality, cheap offsets, with 87% not providing real and additional emissions reductions.
An investigation in 2023 by the Guardian revealed that more than 90% of the rainforest credits offered by one of the world’s leading offsetting companies were “worthless”.
Tree planting for good?
Looking at the current state of the climate, we obviously need to plant more trees. They are not only an extremely effective and natural way of capturing carbon, they also provide shelter, habitats, and protect our soil.
The problem with using trees as carbon offsets comes down to three things:
- timescale
- land space
- environmental impact of plantations
Trees take a long time to grow: about 15-30 years to reach maturity. Trees like the mountain ash live for around 100 years, whereas oak trees can grow for several centuries. It takes an entire lifespan of a tree to absorb a tonne of carbon. That means that just one return flight from the UK to New York wouldn’t be fully compensated within your lifetime.
There’s also no guarantee the tree would reach maturity, or live that long, especially considering our passion for deforestation. And with temperatures rising, it’s growing more and more likely that trees go up in smoke – resulting in an overall increase in emissions.
So rather than plant one tree, and hope it grows, offsetting companies plant many trees in order to compensate for our emissions. The trouble is, that takes up a lot of land space. There isn’t enough space on the planet to plant enough trees to make up for all of our emissions.
And even though we love trees, and need more of them, offset plantations can do more harm than good. Plantations replace biodiverse land with large stretches of one tree species which reduces biodiversity, displaces plant and animal species and reduces the quality of the soil overall.
Social implications and questions of justice
It’s not just the effectiveness that we need to question. Some offsetting schemes have been likened to colonialism because they involve powerful actors in high-carbon societies (traditionally the west) outsourcing emissions reductions to low carbon ones, for example, small indigenous communities. There’s quite a distasteful power imbalance there.
Land is sometimes forcibly taken for offset schemes. An investigation by the Rainforest Foundation found that in the Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC), 103 million hectares had been bought by private companies to make space for carbon projects. These projects often go ahead without community consent and operate in a similar way as logging and mining which has caused deforestation across the DRC. ‘Land grabs’ even happen right here in the UK.
Another popular offsetting project involves providing clean cookstoves for communities in countries across Africa. There is no doubt that these schemes are hugely beneficial to the communities involved, both from the users’ point of view and the planet.
But for all of these schemes, it doesn’t feel right that we should take land in other parts of the world or pay for other people to reduce their emissions just so we can avoid reducing our own.
How much is a tonne of carbon worth?
Carbon pricing matters because it signifies that polluters have to pay a price for their behaviour. The Grantham Institute on climate change calculates that a realistic price for a tonne of carbon in 2050 would be £160.
If we look at most carbon offset calculators, the suggested amount is a lot lower:
- Atmosfair = £20 per tonne CO2
- BA = £10 per tonne (BA has since stopped offering carbon offsets)
- Easyjet = £3 per tonne (EasyJet abandoned its offset scheme in 2022, preferring to focus on green technology and so-called ‘sustainable’ aviation fuel)
There are no hard and fast rules about regulating the cost of carbon, so carbon offsetting becomes regulated by the industry. Ultimately, offsetting has become just another tradable commodity.
Influencing consumer behaviour
The main problem with offsets is that they make us think our emissions don’t count, so we continue our polluting behaviour. If we believe that the harm caused by our flights has been balanced out elsewhere, there’s no incentive for us to cut down.
This is the main reason that Flight Free UK doesn’t support carbon offsetting in any form. While some carbon reduction projects are worthwhile and can have a positive impact, they should be supported for their own merit, rather than being used to allow our emissions to keep on rising.